This month, we’re looking at something we’re increasingly seeing more of, particularly in the wake of Covid and the move towards more flexible-working: the question of whether an individual should be considered a ‘contractor’ or an ’employee’.

More often, businesses are engaging individuals as self-employed, partly because they feel that this offers them greater flexibility (as opposed to employing a full or part-time member of staff), whilst still gaining access to the specialist skills and talent they require.

But herein lies a common mistake – employment status is actually determined by the true nature of the working relationship, and not by the title in an agreement. In this article, we’ll explore how businesses can accurately assess the reality of the working agreements they have in place, and take practical steps if needed to rectifying them.

The Contract is Not the Whole Story

Many companies believe that having a contract which states someone is self-employed is enough to keep the boundaries clear. 

Unfortunately, it isn’t.

If HMRC or an Employment Tribunal investigates the arrangement, they will look beyond the written agreement and examine what actually happens in practice, on a day-to-day basis.

A well-drafted agreement may offer little protection if the day-to-day working relationship actually more closely reflects what is considered to be employment status.

The key question will always be: “What is the reality of the relationship?”

Employment-Status-Canva-Aflo-Images-from-アフロ（Aflo.png

What Actually Determines Employment Status?

Employment-Status-Canva-glegorly-from-Getty-Images-Signature.png

While there is no single litmus test, several important factors should be considered when assessing an individual’s employment status:

The Most Common Warning Signs:

🚩 They work exclusively for your business.

🚩 They work fixed hours every week.

🚩 They use company equipment and resources.

🚩 They need permission to take time off.

🚩 They are managed in the same way as employees.

🚩 They have worked continuously for the business for a long period.

One red flag alone may not be enough to indicate the true nature of employment status, but several of them together should prompt a review.

Why Employment Status Matters

An individual’s employment status determines their legal rights and tax obligations.

Employees are entitled to legal statutory protections, including:

  • Paid annual leave
  • Statutory Sick Pay
  • Family leave rights
  • Redundancy pay
  • Protection from unfair dismissal
  • National Minimum Wage protections

A genuinely self-employed individual typically operates as an independent business and takes responsibility for their own tax, National Insurance and business risks. They also would be expected to set their own working hours.

Employment-Status-Canva-Zimmytwss-Images.png

The Cost of Getting It Wrong

Misclassifying workers can be an expensive mistake to rectify.

Employment-Status-Canva-doidam10.png

If an individual successfully challenges their status, a business could face claims for:

  • Unpaid holiday pay
  • National Minimum Wage arrears
  • Unfair dismissal
  • Redundancy payments
  • Pension contributions
  • Statutory notice pay

There may also be tax implications. HMRC could determine that PAYE and National Insurance contributions should have been deducted, potentially leading to substantial liabilities, interest and penalties.

In addition to financial costs, disputes can damage employee relations and a company’s reputation, and the newly created Fair Work Agency or HMRC may want to take a deeper dive into your business.

Here Are Some Practical Steps:

If you do engage self-employed contractors, now is a good time to review those arrangements.

Businesses should:

  • Review contracts regularly.
  • Assess the reality of working relationships.
  • Ensure managers understand the differences between employees and contractors.
  • Keep arrangements under review as roles evolve over time.
  • Seek professional advice where status is unclear.

Remember, employment status can change.

Someone who starts out as a genuine freelancer may gradually become integrated into the business in a way that creates employment or worker rights. What is most important is that organisations stay on top of these relationships, so that changes can be made where necessary.

Employment-Status-Canva-designer491-from-Getty-Images.png

Prevention is Better Than Cure

Employment status is not always straightforward, but taking the time to get it right can save significant time, money and stress in the future.

The question isn’t simply how someone is labelled, it’s whether the reality of the relationship matches that label.

When it comes to employment status, getting it right from the outset is one of the smartest investments a business can make!

Need Support?

If you are unsure whether your contractors, consultants or freelancers are genuinely self-employed, our team can help.

We provide practical employment status reviews and contract assessments to help minimise your risk and stay compliant.

Contact us by emailing us at hello@metrohr.co.uk – or click the button below to book a call:

Book your FREE 30-minute consulation

Responsive site designed and developed by